Then and Now: Worst Accounting Scandals in the US History v. 2023

The history of the United States is replete with notorious accounting scandals, like the collapse of Lehman Brothers (2008) and the shocking demise of Enron (2001). These scandals shook the nation’s economy, leaving a trail of deception and destruction. The problem of dishonesty in financial dealings has remained the same in modern times.

Federal Trade Commission reports show consumers lost $8.8 billion to fraud in 2022 alone. The statistics underline the persistent threat that fraudulent activities pose to individuals and the economy. With newly implemented DeFi (Decentralized Finance) technology in the picture, there’s no telling how deep this trail runs.

The narrative extends beyond the past, with 2023 revealing a new wave of audacious deceptions, presenting unparalleled challenges for fraud examiners and investigators.

In this article, we explore the depths of financial deceit, armed with innovation and knowledge, to fortify the future against the shadows of financial fraud. We will also look extensively into some of the more recent scandals and their consequences outside finance.

Unraveling the Five Most Devastating Accounting Scandals in U.S. History

Throughout the history of the U.S., corporations have often twisted their financial statements to create a more appealing image for stakeholders and investors. Examples like Enron’s hidden losses and WorldCom’s exaggerated profits have misled many. Bernie Madoff’s notorious Ponzi scheme further highlights the extreme measures some have taken in financial deception.

Let’s take a deeper dive into the 5 most notorious scandals in the US history:

Enron Scandal

In the late 1990s, Enron was a top energy company. But by 1998, they started using tricks to hide their money troubles. To look richer, they lied about earnings, especially when partnering with Blockbuster in movies.

Behind the scenes, they were losing billions. The CEO used mark-to-market accounting tricks to pretend they made profits. Arthur Andersen, a big accounting firm, checked Enron’s books and said all was good, even when it wasn’t.

By 2001, doubts grew about Enron’s real worth. It wasn’t just insiders; reporters like Dan McCrum were raising questions too. Investigations started, and in October, the truth spilled out. Enron admitted to inflating its income levels by $586 million and that it had been doing so since 1997. Enron’s stock crashed.

The aftermath was huge. Enron declared bankruptcy by December 2001. Their deceit hurt Arthur Andersen so much that the firm closed.

To prevent such scams, in 2002, the government set a new rule: the Sarbanes-Oxley Act. This federal law introduced strict financial disclosure and compliance rules. Amending SEC regulations, the act redefined financial reporting and audits for publicly traded companies.

WorldCom Scandal

WorldCom, founded in 1983, swiftly emerged as a major player in the U.S. telecom market. Their meteoric rise was largely attributed to the acquisition of numerous telecom companies, especially after AT&T’s breakup. By the DotCom bubble era, their valuation had skyrocketed to $175 billion.

However, when businesses began reducing their telecom expenses, WorldCom was cornered into a challenging financial position. In an attempt to hide these financial strains, they “cooked the books,” misrepresenting certain expenses and inflating their profits for 2001 and 2002.

Cynthia Cooper, from WorldCom’s internal audit team, was instrumental in uncovering these deceptive practices. The financial manipulation was vast, amounting to about $79.5 billion. Moreover, the company found itself swamped in considerable debt.

Following the revelation, CEO Bernard Ebbers was sentenced to 25 years in prison, while CFO Scott Sullivan received a 5-year term. By 2006, Verizon Communications stepped in to acquire what was left of WorldCom. This scandal was a catalyst for the U.S. government to enact the Sarbanes Oxley Act in 2002, setting forth stricter financial regulations to deter such malfeasance in the future.

Bernie Madoff Accounting Scandal

Bernard Lawrence Madoff, an American financier, executed the largest Ponzi scheme over 17 years, defrauding investors of billions of dollars.

Bernard Lawrence Madoff began his trading career with penny stocks and quickly pivoted to electronic trading, where he found notable success. By the late 1980s, his expertise allowed him to amass upwards of $100 million annually. This rapid ascent led to him becoming the chair of Nasdaq by 1990.

Leveraging his reputation, Madoff introduced the split-strike conversion strategy, enticing investors with promises of substantial and consistent returns. In reality, he was orchestrating an elaborate Ponzi scheme, using funds from new investors to pay returns to earlier ones. 

While this deceitful model enabled many to realize profits, it left several organizations financially devastated. The facade began to crumble in late 2008 when the market took a downturn. 

Amid mounting suspicions, Madoff confessed to his elaborate scam. Financial Analyst Harry Markopolos had been an early voice of dissent, raising red flags about Madoff’s operations. 

In 2009, Madoff received a 150-year prison sentence and was mandated to relinquish $170 billion.

The Lehman Brothers Scandal

Founded in 1850, Lehman Brothers had grown over the years to become one of the world’s leading investment banks. The firm played a major role in the mortgage market, and as the U.S. housing market boomed in the early 2000s, Lehman Brothers invested heavily in Mortgage-Backed Securities (MBS) and Collateral Debt Obligations (CDOs).

However, as the housing market began to show signs of strain and default rates on subprime mortgages rose in 2007, the value of these securities started to drop. Lehman Brothers found itself holding a large number of declining assets, and its share prices began to plummet. 

Despite the clear vulnerabilities, Lehman continued to report healthy financial conditions, in part due to an accounting technique known as “Repo 105,” which temporarily removed liabilities from the balance sheet.

As the credit crisis intensified in 2008, confidence in Lehman Brothers eroded, and its access to borrowing was restricted. Attempts to secure capital, including talks about potential takeovers by Barclays and Bank of America, ultimately failed.

On September 15, 2008, unable to secure further funding or find a buyer, Lehman Brothers filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. This remains the largest bankruptcy filing in U.S. history. The collapse of Lehman Brothers sent shockwaves throughout the global financial system, intensifying what would become the most severe economic downturn since the Great Depression.

The Lehman Brothers scandal brought to light many issues, including risky investment practices, lax regulatory oversight, and the dangers of complex financial products that were poorly understood even by those investing in them. In the aftermath, regulators worldwide made efforts to tighten financial regulations to prevent a similar crisis in the future.

General Electric Accounting Scandal

Beginning in 1986 with its acquisition of Kidder, Peabody & Co., General Electric (GE) faced its first accusation of insider trading. Subsequent investigations led to a $25.3 million settlement with the SEC. However, the controversies didn’t stop there. A trader was found taking advantage of a computer glitch to fabricate profits, with his actions representing over 25% of the fixed-income division’s earnings.

As the Great Recession hit in 2008, GE faced a deepening pension deficit, eventually seeing its pension fund drop by $6.8 billion. The company’s questionable financial practices persisted. Widespread irregularities in reporting prompted another SEC settlement, this time amounting to $50 million. Time and again, the SEC’s scrutiny forced GE’s CFO to adjust their financial statements.

These persistent financial discrepancies drew comparisons to major scandals; some even claimed GE’s accounting issues surpassed those of both Enron and WorldCom. The company has faced criticism for allegedly modifying its financial reporting styles to deter analysts from longitudinal evaluations of their records. 

By 2018, GE announced a staggering loss of $6.2 billion. Two years later, in 2020, they conceded to a $200 million penalty for breaches of securities regulations. Markopolos, the whistleblower in the Madoff case, even described GE’s financial troubles as reminiscent of the Enron debacle, coining the term “Enronesque” to capture the gravity of their alleged malpractices.

Also Read: Top 10 Most Notorious Asset Misappropriation Fraud Cases In US History

Exploring the Five Most Startling U.S. Accounting Scandals of 2023

While previous years were marked by notorious financial deceptions, 2023 has seen its share of scandals with trusted names like Wells Fargo, JP Morgan Chase, and Bank of America. These institutions, once beacons of stability, have faced allegations ranging from sanctions violations to fraudulent practices. The incidents underscore the unending challenges in upholding integrity within the financial industry. 

Let’s delve into these startling scandals in detail:

Wells Fargo 

In 2023, Wells Fargo once again found itself in the crosshairs of regulators, being fined nearly $100 million over sanctions violations. The Federal Reserve Board and the Treasury Department took this action after the bank was found to have allowed a foreign bank to process $532 million of prohibited transactions on its Eximbills platform between 2010 to 2015.

This was, unfortunately, not an isolated incident in the bank’s recent history. Reflecting on past events, Wells Fargo has been marred by a series of financial scandals:

  • For over a decade, the bank faced accusations of its employees creating fake accounts without customer consent, driven by intense sales targets. These illicit actions resulted in a plethora of fees and interest that customers hadn’t approved. This significant breach of trust led to a landmark fine of $3 billion in 2020, settling a civil lawsuit instigated by the SEC.
  • By 2022, the bank’s practices were under even more scrutiny. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau highlighted further misconduct and imposed penalties on Wells Fargo. They were directed to pay $2 billion in refunds and an additional $1.7 billion in penalties. These directives were associated with a slew of consumer financial law violations, most notably involving unsanctioned fees and interest on auto and mortgage loans.

Despite the bank’s public commitments to reform, these consecutive scandals underscore the critical importance of robust compliance systems and meticulous internal controls within financial institutions. They serve as a somber reminder of the vigilance required to maintain trust in the banking sector.

Frank Butselaar’s $100 Million Tax Evasion

Frank Butselaar, a citizen of the Netherlands, was charged with engaging in tax fraud for over seven years. Butselaar advised his clients to establish offshore accounts, later used to hide income from the IRS. The entities were held by trusts, with the client’s family members as the beneficiaries. 

Butselaar and his co-conspirators were accused of devising strategies to file fraudulent returns with the IRS. If found guilty, they could be sentenced to up to five years in prison and additional three years for each false tax filing. 

The Joe Lewis Scandal

British billionaire Joe Lewis was recently indicted for “orchestrating a brazen insider trading scheme.” The US attorney for the southern district of New York alleged that he gave insider information to his contacts, including his friends and personal assistants. 

The Department of Justice also alleged that he routinely provided inside corporate information to his associates, who made millions via stock trades. Following over a dozen charges, including securities fraud and his indictment in New York, his attorney claims that the government has made an “egregious error” in charging Lewis.

JP Morgan Chase Defraudment Scandal

Charlie Javice, the founder of Frank, a college financial planning company, was charged by the Department of Justice for defrauding JP Morgan Chase into believing that they had a user base of over 4 million. 

According to the authorities, Charlie fabricated Frank’s data to look like it served more students than it did. She now faces banking, securities, and wire fraud charges as she stood to make $45 million through the deal. This case underscores the importance of accurately representing business metrics and the need for thorough due diligence before acquisitions.

Bank of America Scandal

In a recent revelation, the Bank of America has been accused of utilizing a “Double-dipping Scheme” to squeeze out junk fees from its customers. The bank made tens of millions of dollars by charging $35 for insufficient funds and repeatedly charging fees for the same transaction. 

Additionally, the bank’s charged with opening accounts without customers and withholding reward bonuses.

In response to the aforementioned charges, the bank has been ordered to pay over $100 million to customers. Additionally, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau imposed a penalty of $150 million for the same charges.

However, Bank of America’s Senior VP announced that the bank had voluntarily reduced overdraft fees and expelled insufficient fund fees. The changes have led to a substantial drop in revenue of over 90% from these fees. 

Parting Thoughts

As financial fraud continues to evolve, so must our methods of combating it. While the past scandals were rooted in traditional forms of financial manipulation, the recent ones reflect the exploitation of technology and digital platforms for illicit gain.

This shift emphasizes the urgent need for financial institutions and regulators to leverage technology in their fight against fraud. Advanced analytics, artificial intelligence, and machine learning are no longer optional tools; they are essential for detecting and preventing increasingly complex fraudulent activities.

Let’s harness the power of technology to react and disrupt these illicit activities proactively. Together, we can redefine the landscape of financial integrity and ensure a safer, more transparent future for all. 


Try ScanWriter Today